{ "schemaVersion": 1, "supersedesPublicQueueId": "HRQ-B8270C19F14C1E73", "policy": { "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "humanReviewerRoleExists": false, "separateRoleRunsRequired": true, "adversarialCriticRequired": true, "correlatedErrorMustBeDisclosed": true, "agentConsensusIsEmpiricalEvidence": false, "agentConsensusIsClinicalEfficacy": false, "claimEvidencePromotionRequiresSeparateLedger": true, "finalLegalEthicsAndReleaseApprovalOutsideResearchAdjudication": true, "pendingIsNegativeEvidence": false, "workUnitsAreAdditiveUniqueSources": false, "synthesisPermitted": false }, "summary": { "lanes": 13, "p0Lanes": 1, "p1Lanes": 11, "p2Lanes": 1, "completedAgenticLanes": 2, "agentReviewedWorkUnits": 10, "agentRoleJudgments": 30, "discussionCandidates": 1, "revisionRequired": 9, "unclearCandidates": 1, "evidenceEligibleLanes": 0, "synthesisPermitted": false }, "lanes": [ { "id": "ARQ-CLASSICAL-FACSIMILE", "priority": "P0", "kind": "classical-facsimile-alignment", "packetId": "DNI-A72DE3D921CE4A8E", "workbenchId": "CFWB-476F7A959EB67E7E", "facsimilePages": 2, "normalizedLines": 11, "ocrObservations": 0, "agentVisualHints": 2, "requiredChecklistItems": 6, "status": "role-complete-unclear-retained-candidate", "workUnits": 1, "completed": 1, "actionKo": "내부 시각 workbench에서 내경편2 공개 영인본 17–18쪽과 정규화 11개 줄을 자대조한다. 붉은 영역 2개는 에이전트 후보일 뿐이며 세로쓰기 OCR 0건은 텍스트 부재가 아니다. 편·권·문, 표제, 글자, 연속 문맥, 판심·장차/인쇄면, 판정자 독립성 6개 항목을 확인해 Accept/Reject/Unclear 판정", "actionEn": "Use the internal visual workbench to collate 11 normalized lines against public-domain facsimile pages 17–18. Two red regions are agent hints only; zero vertical-text OCR observations do not mean absence of text. Check six items—structure, heading, characters, continuation, printed folio, and reviewer independence—then decide Accept, Reject, or Unclear.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-CLASSICAL-FACSIMILE", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "facsimile-visual-collator", "normalized-text-source-critic", "adversarial-provenance-critic" ], "adjudicationId": "AGCADJ-A4D288C76FC0C415", "completedRoleJudgments": 3, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 1, "unclearCandidates": 1, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Three separate role executions used the same Codex orchestration/provider and inherited model family. Agreement reduces single-prompt error but is not independent external validation." }, { "id": "ARQ-KAROLINSKA-PASSAGES", "priority": "P1", "kind": "modern-passage-review", "packetId": "KIRV-E09121CDAB6DA62C", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 5, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "진단 비경계성·분절·다학제 모델·평균효과와 이질성·감정 관계의 5개 exact-byte passage를 페이지 문맥과 함께 판정", "actionEn": "Review five exact-byte passages in page context on diagnostic boundaries, fragmentation, multidisciplinary models, average effects versus heterogeneity, and emotion relations.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-KAROLINSKA-PASSAGES", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-JAPANESE-KAMPO-PASSAGES", "priority": "P1", "kind": "japanese-kampo-source-passage-dual-review", "packetId": "JKRV-F49D900D94A6E905", "ledgerId": "JKADJ-F04E6AFC52A0B56F", "workbenchId": "JKPW-9590F25F6443E165", "status": "role-complete-revision-required", "workUnits": 9, "distinctSources": 4, "distinctPages": 8, "exactDerivedBytePassages": 9, "minimumIndependentReviews": 2, "requiredJudgments": 18, "completedJudgments": 0, "recordedEvents": 0, "conflicts": 0, "resolved": 0, "completed": 9, "actionKo": "로컬 전체-page workbench에서 오쓰카·데라사와 공식 J-STAGE 논문 4건의 8쪽에 결박된 후보 passage 9건을 독립 2인이 일본어 원문과 PDF 문맥에서 append-only 원장에 판정한다. 기계 추출문은 출판사 PDF byte나 사람 전사가 아니며 증례 반응·도상 유사성·해부 상관을 인과·계보·기전으로 자동 승격하지 않는다.", "actionEn": "Using the local full-page workbench, two independent reviewers record append-only judgments on nine candidates bound to eight pages across four official Otsuka and Terasawa J-STAGE papers. They inspect Japanese source and PDF context; derived machine text is neither publisher-PDF bytes nor human transcription, and case response, diagram similarity, or anatomical association cannot be promoted automatically to causality, lineage, or mechanism.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-JAPANESE-KAMPO-PASSAGES", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-history-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "clinical-translation-safety-critic" ], "adjudicationId": "AGADJ-4CF02B267C931650", "completedRoleJudgments": 27, "discussionCandidates": 1, "revisionRequired": 8, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Runs used separate agent executions and adversarial roles but the same orchestration/provider context and an undisclosed inherited model family; correlated errors remain possible." }, { "id": "ARQ-AUT-SUGAR-TRAJECTORY", "priority": "P1", "kind": "modern-passage-and-version-review", "packetId": "AUTRV-C73035B426275E73", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 5, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "설탕 감량 중 SUD 유사 증상의 궤적·이질성·경쟁설명·기능장애 한계 5개 passage와 preprint↔출판본 version identity를 함께 판정", "actionEn": "Review five passages on trajectories, heterogeneity, competing explanations, and functional-impairment limits during sugar reduction, together with preprint-to-publication version identity.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-AUT-SUGAR-TRAJECTORY", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-OPENAIRE-REPOSITORY-VERSION", "priority": "P1", "kind": "repository-version-license-relevance-review", "packetId": "OAIRV-44AFA3192A6BF042", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 3, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "서로 다른 두 repository PDF의 동일 출판본문 여부, VOR·CC BY-NC 표지 신호의 재사용 의미, 서비스 이질성 결과의 임상·조직 관련성을 각각 판정", "actionEn": "Adjudicate whether two repository PDFs contain the same published body, what their VOR and CC BY-NC cover signals permit, and whether the service-heterogeneity findings are clinically and organizationally relevant.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-OPENAIRE-REPOSITORY-VERSION", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-OSF-ARTIFACT-RELEVANCE", "priority": "P1", "kind": "artifact-version-relevance-passage-license-review", "packetId": "OSFRV-29DAAB7F340EE85E", "supplementaryPacketId": "OSFPC-8EF2C52AAB00AFB3", "workbenchId": "OSFPW-ADB282849B176224", "machinePassageCandidates": 33, "exactByteRoundtrips": 33, "taskLensPairsWithoutSignal": 3, "highSignalFirst": 3, "standardReview": 3, "lowSpecificityControls": 7, "noSignalControls": 3, "ledgerId": "OSFADJ-C71D129F43FD7FF0", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 14, "doiFamilyUnits": 15, "requiredEvents": 14, "recordedEvents": 0, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "OSF/MetaArXiv 원문 14건(15 DOI family)의 identity·version·관련성·정확 passage·license 적용을 append-only ledger에 판정. 문맥 workbench는 16개 task-lens를 강신호 우선 3·표준 3·저특이도 통제 7·무신호 통제 3으로 분리하고 exact-byte 후보 33개를 결박한다. 우선순위는 사람 관련성 판정이 아니다.", "actionEn": "Adjudicate identity, version, relevance, exact passages, and license applicability for 14 OSF/MetaArXiv artifacts spanning 15 DOI families. The contextual workbench partitions 16 task-lens units into three high-signal-first, three standard, seven low-specificity controls, and three no-signal controls while binding 33 exact-byte candidates. Priority is not a human relevance judgment.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-OSF-ARTIFACT-RELEVANCE", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-JSIM-RELATED-VERSION", "priority": "P1", "kind": "source-and-related-artifact-version-passage-license-review", "packetId": "MORRV-5C3B759E02CE8FEF", "ledgerId": "MORADJ-18A667A02134CF4D", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 4, "requiredEvents": 1, "recordedEvents": 0, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "공식 Morressier 원 포스터 PDF와 CC BY 4.0 JSIM JATS를 함께 열어 메타데이터/포스터/출판본 저자 1/3/2명, 메타데이터 제목 일치와 포스터 제목 불일치, 공통 문구 8개를 대조한다. 4개 exact-byte passage의 양쪽 지지 여부, same work/version 관계, 원 포스터 license code 3의 재사용 의미를 append-only ledger에 판정", "actionEn": "Open the official Morressier source poster PDF and CC BY 4.0 JSIM JATS together. Compare the 1/3/2 metadata-poster-publication author sets, metadata-title match, poster-title mismatch, and eight shared phrases; adjudicate support on both sides for four exact-byte passages, the same-work/version relationship, and whether source license code 3 permits reuse in the append-only ledger.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-JSIM-RELATED-VERSION", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-DIANZISHU-SOURCE-AUDIT", "priority": "P1", "kind": "historical-source-audit", "packetId": "DSAUD-0E3A36A7D237AA43", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 1, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "본문의 역사 문헌명 22개에 대해 실제 판본·권차·면 locator, 저자 identity, 라이선스를 확인하고 주장별 추적 가능성을 판정", "actionEn": "Verify edition-volume-page locators for 22 named historical works, author identity, license, and claim-level traceability.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-DIANZISHU-SOURCE-AUDIT", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-PREPRINT-DUAL-RELEVANCE", "priority": "P1", "kind": "independent-dual-relevance", "packetId": "PP2ADJ-3CD6684075CF3E03", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 24, "requiredJudgments": 48, "completedJudgments": 0, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "12개 lens의 24개 DOI family를 후보당 독립 2회 판정하고 충돌은 제3자 해결 원장으로 보냄", "actionEn": "Adjudicate 24 DOI families across 12 lenses twice independently; route disagreements to the third-party resolution ledger.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-PREPRINT-DUAL-RELEVANCE", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-AUTHORITY-RELEVANCE-CALIBRATION", "priority": "P1", "kind": "authority-identity-and-relevance-dual-calibration", "packetId": "ARCP-71F606EFBE3B4745", "ledgerId": "ARCADJ-B01BCF62263044B2", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 10, "requiredJudgments": 20, "completedJudgments": 0, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "황황·황룡상 이름을 포함한 broad HanScope 상위 후보 10건을 후보당 독립 2회 판정한다. 동일 인물/명시적 계보 관계와 주제 관련성을 별도 축으로 기록하고, 충돌은 독립 제3자가 해결한다. 10건 전부 합의·해결되기 전에는 부분 관측 오탐률을 최종 오탐률로 발표하지 않는다.", "actionEn": "Independently review each of ten top broad HanScope candidates returned by Huang Huang and Huang Longxiang name-bearing queries. Record person/lineage identity relation separately from topical relevance, resolve conflicts through an independent third reviewer, and do not publish a partial observed false-positive rate as the final rate before all ten candidates reach consensus or resolution.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-AUTHORITY-RELEVANCE-CALIBRATION", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-OASIS-PASSAGES", "priority": "P1", "kind": "korean-specialist-passage-review", "packetId": "OPREV-BC62FC243144B75B", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 18, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "OASIS 우선 문헌 10편의 passage 후보 18개를 원 PDF 문맥에서 검토하고, 이미지 전용 4편은 시각 대조", "actionEn": "Review 18 passage candidates from ten priority OASIS papers in original-PDF context, including visual inspection of four image-only documents.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-OASIS-PASSAGES", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-PAPERQA-GOLD", "priority": "P1", "kind": "retrieval-benchmark-gold", "packetId": "PQGR-DIAGNOSTIC-BOUNDARY-V1", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 19, "questionUnits": 6, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "PaperQA 평가 질문 6개와 passage 19개를 원문 문맥에서 판정해 모델이 자기 benchmark를 승인하지 못하게 함", "actionEn": "Adjudicate six PaperQA questions and 19 passages in source context so the model cannot certify its own benchmark.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-PAPERQA-GOLD", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." }, { "id": "ARQ-QGRAPH-BROAD-TRIAGE", "priority": "P2", "kind": "broad-candidate-relevance", "packetId": "QREV-92A16B39C085B730", "status": "pending-agentic-adjudication", "workUnits": 182, "completed": 0, "actionKo": "37개 질문의 상위 후보 182개를 direct/contextual/counterevidence/irrelevant/uncertain으로 판정. P1 calibration wave와 중복될 수 있어 합산 고유 문헌 수로 해석하지 않음", "actionEn": "Classify 182 top candidates across 37 questions as direct, contextual, counterevidence, irrelevant, or uncertain. This may overlap the P1 calibration wave and is not an additive unique-source count.", "evidenceEligible": false, "legacyLaneId": "HRQ-QGRAPH-BROAD-TRIAGE", "reviewSubject": "research-agents", "requiredAgentRoles": [ "source-integrity-critic", "adversarial-counterevidence-critic", "domain-translation-critic" ], "adjudicationId": null, "completedRoleJudgments": 0, "discussionCandidates": 0, "revisionRequired": 0, "unclearCandidates": 0, "correlatedErrorWarning": "Agent-role execution has not started; model-family and provider diversity are not yet measured." } ], "queueId": "ARQ-ECF2F70CFD4D94C7" }